A Tontine too Far (away)

5 Jul 12th, 2007

Advantages:
great food, excellent service, decent prices, lovely bistro bar

Disadvantages:
Too far away

Recommendable: Yes 

Detailed rating:

Quality of Rooms

Standard of Service

Quality of Food & Drink

Quality of Facilities

more


fightgear

About me: Lover of fast cars, technology, martial arts and photography. Used to work as a magazine writer and ...

Member since:11.07.2007

Reviews:56

Members who trust:2

Review rated by 13 Ciao members on average: very helpful

We had driven past this restaurant many times while travelling up the A19 in North Yorkshire. A few years ago we heard it won an award for its food and so always thought we would have to try it one day.

For a surprise, my wife booked it for my birthday. It was a 30 minute drive and we knew that it wasn't the cheapest of meals there. The restaurant is right on the edge of the busy A19 so its not exactly peaceful. There is plenty of parking available as it is pretty much alone in the middle of nowhere.

Arriving, we were met at the door and shown into a bar where we could look at the menu before being seated. The bar is quite small as is the restaurant but it is decidedly cosy. The kind of place where you would want to take someone special for a special meal.

The menu had some great dishes on it. Very rustic and filling. We had a minestroni soup and pate with home made bread as starter both of which tasted as though they had been made minutes before and just for us. The servings were plentiful and well presented. As our main course my wife had an incredible steak which she still says was the best she has ever eaten while I had a medley of meats and seasonal vegetables. Both of these were delicious. Cooked to perfection and we locally produced. North Yorkshire is a sturdy place and produces sturdy meals. The desert we chose was a panne cota and creme bruille which were melt in the mouth delicious. The choices of wines were excellent with some vintage wine available if you can afford it.

If memory serves me right, the whole meal cost around £60 for the two of us including drinks and bottled water. Service was first class throughout. Then made you feel really special which is a nice way to feel on your birthday.

About a week later we returned again for a Sunday lunch. This was fixed price and again was superb. Full plates, great service and a lovely atmosphere. I only wish it was closer

Such a fabulous place and somewhere that Vic Reeves and Bob Mortimer both said was the best restaurant in England

Evaluate this review

How helpful would this review be to someone making a buying decision?

Rating guidelines

Comments about this review
Miskah

Miskah

15.07.2007 00:42

great review, nicely written. ♥Beth.

Add your comment

max. 2000 characters

  Post comment


Review Ratings
This review of McCoy's, Staddlebridge has been rated:

"very helpful" by (62%):
  1. Miskah
  2. rd52169
  3. thebigc1690
and 5 other members

"helpful" by (38%):
  1. christianfilmcritic
  2. sarahbarrow
  3. Claiiiree
and 2 other members

The overall rating of a review is different from a simple average of all individual ratings.
Products you might be interested in
Macdonald Last Drop Village Hotel & Spa, Bolton Macdonald Last Drop Village Hotel & Spa, Bolton
Hotel - Hospital Road, Bromley Cross, Bolton, Greater Manchester, BL7 9PZ - 3 Stars - 128 Rooms
3 reviews
Buy now for only £ 49.57
Best Western Chine Hotel, Bournemouth Best Western Chine Hotel, Bournemouth
Hotel - Boscombe Spa Road, Bournemouth, Dorset, BH5 1AX - 2 Stars - 89 Rooms
1 review
Buy now for only £ 39.65
Related tags for McCoy's, Staddlebridge
Related products on eBay