Quote-start

Well worth considering but certain Flaws exist

Quote-end

3 Mar 20th, 2007 

12 Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful

Advantages:
Luxurious New Trains, Friendly Staff and Well planned timetable

Disadvantages:
Extortionate fares, Very Unreliable, Poor On - Train Security

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Frequency of trains

Reliability of trains

Comfort of trains

On-board facilities

aaron_manz

aaron_manz

About me:

Member since:02.10.2004

Reviews:3

As a student i have the need to use a South West Trains service from Surbiton to Weybridge and also travel occasionaly into London Waterloo from Hampton Court.

When i travel from Surbiton the trains at peak time are frequent - every 5-10 minutes. The station staff do help but sometimes are busy dealing with other procedures. The fleet of trains used are very nice with new Class 455's (red blue metro style) and the long distance 450's and 444's.

The desiro trains are spacious and more comfortable than the older class 455's, which have all windows scratched, no CCTV and moderate risk of attack or muging on late night services.
I'm not sure how bad they would be in summer but can immagine that air-con failures will get passengers into a terrible mood.

I am worried about the lack of Guards visible on-train and revenue protection staff which should be visible tackling fare evaders. No wonder revenue is cut short if staff are cut short!
I also have never encountered the so-called "Travel Safe" officers on trains, only saw them at London Waterloo, do they think robotic CCTV will replace real security?

This also links onto their "Rip-Off" fares. Yes if you are within Zones 1-6 and you travel Off Peak you can get travelcards for as low as £4! But when you start talking about peak fares you will be shocked: From Esher to London Waterloo Travelcard costs £16!!! Also my single ticket from Surbiton to Weybridge is £3!!!
Doesn't sound much but considering it is only 2 stations away it's quite a premium to pay.

Season tickets may be good value for £2000 a year but i think that Free car parking needs to be incorporated to encourage more season ticket purchases

As for the Unreliability, some trains are delayed by about 15 minutes and all just because it left late from London Waterloo or it's Terminus. South West Trains need to run more trains on time and consider what a difference the lateness makes to people's commutes

All in all travel standards are improving but you need to consider: is there a faster and more reliable way to complete my journey?  

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Dakine 60/40 Split Convertible Travel Bag 2009 Deuter Speedlite 10
Crumpler Gimp 15 inch Laptop Sleeve Deuter Attack
Crumpler Gimp 17 inch Laptop Sleeve Dakine Campus

Comments about this review »

wingnut888 21.03.2007 01:27

hi and welcome to ciao

darkangelwing 20.03.2007 19:22

A terrific debut review, well done.

CareBear 20.03.2007 18:32

I paid just under £3000 for my season from Woking to Waterloo and then an additional 700 for the car park! The car park is not even next to the station - it takes 10 minutes to walk to the station entrance!

Related offers for South West Trains »

NH Hoteles 0 Ratings

NH Hoteles

NH Hotels, the hotel chain leader in Europe, with more than 300 hotels in 20 countries in Europe, Latin America and Africa. Enter into our web site and find the best available tariff at all times

 Visit Shop  >
NH Hoteles
Record Rent a Car 7 Ratings

Record Rent a Car

Record Rent a Car is present in the main spanish airports and has a very wide fleet. We offer: exceptional discounts, free additional drivers, unlimited mileage... subscribe to our Club Record and take advantage of special offers.

 Visit Shop  >
Record Rent a Car


More reviews »

South West Trains - review by whytelexie

Advantages: Most of the trains arrive on time
Disadvantages: The other 30 or so percent are late

South West Trains - review by whytelexie whytelexie 15.01.2003 (13.02.2003) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of South West Trains

South West Trains - review by vc-10

Advantages: Clean, efficient, friendly staff
Disadvantages: not enough frequency to some stations

South West Trains - review by vc-10 vc-10 06.02.2008 (06.02.2008) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of South West Trains

South West Trains - review by WILMA

Advantages: Cheap sometimes
Disadvantages: never there when you want one

South West Trains - review by WILMA WILMA 08.03.2001 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of South West Trains

South West Trains - review by smcclt3006

Advantages: Value for money, new or refubished clean trains, reliability
Disadvantages: NONE

South West Trains - review by smcclt3006 smcclt3006 07.08.2007 (18.08.2007) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of South West Trains

South West Trains - review by ploddy100

Advantages: Getting better service, quick to London
Disadvantages: Less stops at smaller stations

South West Trains - review by ploddy100 ploddy100 20.07.2005 (20.07.2005) · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: helpful
Review of South West Trains



Are you the manufacturer / provider of South West Trains? Click here