Quote-start

Sheffield's Controversial Supertram!

Quote-end

5 Jan 6th, 2007 

59 Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful

Advantages:
Fast, Cheap and Comfortable

Disadvantages:
Does Not Serve The Whole City, Often Congested

Recommendable Yes:

Detailed rating:

Value for Money

micksheff

micksheff

About me:

Member since:18.07.2003

Reviews:706

Members who trust:220

Historically the City of Sheffield had an extensive Tram System that served the City from the late 1880's until 1960 when it was abolished. It had been perceived by the late 1950's that the future of travel in the City would be with Cars.

Twenty five years later and there were so many Cars on the Roads that the City's transport infrastructure was on the verge of complete collapse. Clearly something radical had to be done and a Government funded study concluded that the future of travel in Sheffield would once again lie in the hands of the Trams.

These new Trams would be a far cry from the old Victorian Trams that had once graced our streets, they would be fast, clean and environmentally friendly. Lessons could be learned from similar schemes in other UK Cities like Manchester and the latest technology available would make these Trams cutting edge.

And so the Supertrams as they were to be called were born.

The early days of the Supertram were not however without controversy. The major construction work on the City's Streets between 1991 and 1995 that was required to create the City's new state of the art transport system created chaos on the already congested Roads and by the time this work was completed hundreds of small Businesses had been forced to close as the blocked off Roads had made their premises virtually inaccessible to the Public. On top of this the cost of Supertram soared way beyond its original budget and scaremongering within the local Press warned us that it would be the residents of the City that would be picking up the bill.

On the 21st March 1994 the first Supertrams began to run in the City, initially on a route between the City Centre and Meadowhall Interchange. By the 23rd October 1995 all work had been completed and the Supertrams began to run on three different routes consisting of 29 Kilometres of Rail Track. These routes ran from Malin Bridge near Hillsborough to Halfway via the City Centre and the Crystal Peaks Shopping Complex, from Middlewood to the Meadowhall Interchange via the City Centre, and from Herdings Park to the Meadowhall Interchange.

Approximately 50% of the electric driven light Railway track system is at the side or in the middle of Public Roads but Supertram always has priority over the other traffic.

The Supertram network links five different park and ride sites with the City Centre and gives easy access to the Railway Station, Shopping areas, both of Sheffield's prestigious Universities, the Cathedral, Sports Arenas and many other popular entertainment venues.

Each Supertram Vehicle looks like a modern aerodynamic Train and is capable of carrying over 250 Passengers. They are quiet, comfortable and very clean with every vehicle being washed at the end of each days service and fully valeted every month.

In the early days of the Supertram tickets were purchased from machines at the Tram stops prior to boarding and shown to the Driver for verification but this system did not really work. Many people found the fare structure confusing and bought incorrect tickets whilst others used this flaw to deliberately abuse the system. Within a few months these automatic ticket machines were abandoned and all Supertrams now have Conductors on board from whom the tickets are bought from.

All of Sheffield's Supertrams are operated by Stagecoach who also operate local Buses in the City alongside First Mainline and other smaller local Bus Companies. All of the Stagecoach Staff are fully trained in Customer Care, conflict avoidance and Disability awareness.

I travel on the Sheffield Supertram quite regularly since I own a Shop at Hillsborough and there is a Tram stop directly outside it. From the City Centre to Hillsborough the journey by Tram is far quicker than by Bus or Car and also a lot cheaper than by the Bus.

The prices are quite simple and there is a maximum one way fare of just £1.80 or you can buy a Daysaver ticket for £2.70 which you can use as many times as you want during a day.

My fare to Hillsborough costs £1.80 each way so I always buy a Daysaver ticket for £2.70. This compares with a comparative Bus fare on First mainline of £2.10 for a single journey or £3.50 for a Daysaver. There are also concessionary rates for Children, OAP's and Students. For regular travellers there are Weekly and Monthly tickets available. Weekly tickets currently cost £9.50 and Monthly ones £35.

Hillsborough is an area of the City that is notoriously bad for traffic congestion. It is also the location of Sheffield Wednesday's Football Ground and when they are playing at home the traffic is horrendous. The beauty of Supertram is that it has priority over all other traffic and therefore does not have to wait in any traffic queues.

All of the Trams that I have been on have been very clean and the staff have always been polite. The main problem that I find is that they get very crowded at busy times and sometimes I have to stand for my full journey.

The other criticism would have to be that the Supertram does not serve a lot of the City so it is only any good if you live on the route. Since I don't live on the route when I visit my shop (only usually a couple of times a week) I have to catch a Bus from my house to the City Centre before I can jump on a Tram.

A journey on the Sheffield Supertram bears very little resemblance to a journey by Bus. Back in the days when this transport system was still a dream I always imagined that it would have been more akin to a journey by Train but the reality is that there are not even too many similarities there either.

A Supertram ride is a much more comfortable, relaxed affair. Since even the oldest vehicles are still only a few years old the upholstery on the seats is very clean, almost as new on most of the vehicles and I have never seen any graffiti. I understand that all of the original vehicles are now also in a refurbishment programme and will be completely updated within the next couple of years and on top of this there are brand new vehicles on order. It would seem that Stagecoach have no intentions of running this flagship system into the ground as they have done with the Buses that they operate in the City. Many of their Buses are now well over ten years old with torn upholstery and are quite literally falling to bits.

The Supertrams are very quiet. In the early days this caused a few problems as they knocked several people down because unlike the other traffic you cannot hear them coming until they are very close to you. When a Tram pulls up at one of its designated stops the doors slide open automatically. They usually have three or four carriages on them although there are currently plans to add a fifth carriage onto vehicles at peak times to try and reduce congestion. This would seem to be the logical thing to do since increasing the frequency of the Trams would be difficult because there are a limited number of vehicles and during the rush hour they already run every 8 minutes. Adding another carriage however will not be quite as simple as it sounds as many of the stations are not long enough to cope with a vehicle of this length. One such compromise that is currently being discussed is to have people get off the Trams only from the middle three carriages at shorter stations, something that currently happens on some of the London Underground Tube Stations.

Inside the Trams each vehicle is equipped with rows of seats set out in pairs with an aisle in between. Although it has be said that the space between each row of seats and the width of the aisle is a lot wider than those found on our local Buses and many of the Trains that I have travelled on. The seats that are closest to each set of doors have a lot more space in front of them are these are reserved especially for the disabled, elderly and people with pushchairs.

The rows of seats face different directions so you have a choice whether you wish to face forwards or backwards on your journey. In each carriage there is a LCD display advising you of the next stop that are approaching. Trams do not automatically stop at every stop so you do have to press the bell when you reach your destination, although once this has been pressed a message above the station name on the LCD display will say "Stopping at."

Getting on and off the Trams for people in Wheelchairs or with Pushchairs is also a lot less hassle than getting onto a Bus, or so I am told. Although to be fair many of the newer Buses do now have low floors and can tilt downwards to almost ground level. The Supertram however does not have this problem since the station platforms are completely level with the doors and there is virtually no gap between the platform and the door, a problem that still occurs with many Trains.

Overall I think that the Sheffield Supertram is excellent but there are still many people in the City who have not forgotten the chaos and the misery that its construction caused. So opinion is still very much divided between those that were largely unaffected by its creation and love it and those that will never forgive it and loathe it.

Thank you for reading.

 

How helpful would this review be to a person making a buying decision? Rating guidelines

exceptional

very helpful

helpful

somewhat helpful

not helpful

off topic

Products you might be interested in »

Crumpler Gimp 17 inch Laptop Sleeve Dakine Split Roller 100 Travel Bag 2008
Dakine Campus Deuter Speedlite 10
Dakine 60/40 Split Convertible Travel Bag 2009 Crumpler Gimp 15 inch Laptop Sleeve

Comments about this review »

dbirse 08.04.2007 18:32

Very good.

Julieshobs 09.01.2007 13:29

We are supposed to be getting trams back in Liverpool but all seems to have ground to a halt over some trees which are in the way. The argument seems to over the age of these trees but the old tram lines are laid underneath them so they can't be that old. Jules.

little_red_hen 07.01.2007 20:38

Very thorough review, I was totally unaware that they ran in sheffield. Karen

Related offers for The Sheffield Supertram System »

NH Hoteles 0 Ratings

NH Hoteles

NH Hotels, the hotel chain leader in Europe, with more than 300 hotels in 20 countries in Europe, Latin America and Africa. Enter into our web site and find the best available tariff at all times

 Visit Shop  >
NH Hoteles


More reviews »

The Sheffield Supertram System - review by DC-DanielColeflax

Advantages: fast, reliable, safe, cheap, near everything
Disadvantages: some routes illogical and impactical.

The Sheffield Supertram System - review by DC-DanielColeflax DC-DanielColeflax 01.06.2007 · Read review
Ciao members have rated this review on average: very helpful
Review of The Sheffield Supertram System



Are you the manufacturer / provider of The Sheffield Supertram System? Click here